AT&T Stadium was built to host moments that feel oversized. Giant screen. Giant crowds. Giant prices for a bottle of water that somehow tastes like disappointment. Yet for all the grand entrances and pre-game hype, the stadium has developed a habit of embarrassing the favourites.
The Dallas Cowboys have watched plenty of heavily fancied teams walk into Arlington expecting a celebration and leave wondering whether they accidentally wandered into a haunted house with better parking.
These are the biggest upsets to take place at AT&T Stadium, ranked by the scale of the shock, the stakes involved and how badly they ruined somebody’s week.
New York Giants 21, Dallas Cowboys 17, 2022 NFC Wild Card
The Cowboys entered the 2022 season finale having finally put together a roster that looked dangerous in January. Dak Prescott was healthy, Micah Parsons was terrifying offensive coordinators for fun and Dallas had just won 12 games.
Then came the Giants in the Wild Card round. The Giants were not supposed to be here, at least according to most people outside New York. Brian Daboll had done a fine coaching job, but the roster looked like it had been assembled by someone speed-running a rebuild.
Instead, the Giants marched into AT&T Stadium and punched Dallas in the mouth. Daniel Jones played one of the best games of his career. Saquon Barkley found space. The Cowboys offence stalled repeatedly.
The mood inside the stadium shifted from nervous confidence to the familiar Dallas playoff panic. By the fourth quarter, you could practically hear fans preparing their annual speech about how next year would definitely be different.
Why it was an upset:
- Dallas were at home and widely expected to advance.
- The Giants had not won a road playoff game in more than a decade.
- The Cowboys had looked like genuine contenders.
Green Bay Packers 48, Dallas Cowboys 32, 2016 NFC Divisional Round
Technically Green Bay won as the hotter team, but Dallas were still the top seed, still at home and still carrying a 13-3 record. AT&T Stadium was ready for a deep playoff run.
Instead, Aaron Rodgers arrived and spent three hours treating the Cowboys secondary like it had insulted him personally.
The Cowboys fought back from an early deficit behind rookie quarterback Dak Prescott and rookie running back Ezekiel Elliott. Suddenly, Dallas had tied the game late and the crowd was losing its mind.
Then Rodgers completed that ridiculous sideline throw to Jared Cook. You know the one. The pass that somehow bent the laws of geometry and several Cowboys fans into uncomfortable new shapes.
Green Bay kicked the winning field goal and left Dallas with another playoff scar.
What made it shocking:
- Dallas were the NFC’s number one seed.
- Prescott and Elliott had transformed the Cowboys overnight.
- Home-field advantage was supposed to matter. Rodgers politely ignored that.
Baylor 61, TCU 58, 2014
College football chaos belongs in Texas, and this might be the finest example.
TCU entered the game ranked ninth in the country and led Baylor 58-37 in the fourth quarter. The game looked finished. Fans were already thinking about post-game traffic, which is generally the first sign that football is about to do something ridiculous.
Baylor then scored 24 unanswered points in the final eleven minutes. Bryce Petty launched passes all over the field. TCU suddenly forgot how to defend anything with a pulse.
The winning field goal sailed through as time expired, and AT&T Stadium briefly transformed into the emotional equivalent of a fireworks factory exploding.
Why it belongs here:
- Baylor came back from 21 points down in the fourth quarter.
- TCU had dominated most of the game.
- The result helped derail TCU’s College Football Playoff hopes.
Dallas Cowboys 31, New Orleans Saints 17, 2009
Not every upset at AT&T Stadium happened against Dallas. Occasionally, the Cowboys were the underdog and remembered they were allowed to enjoy themselves.
The 2009 Saints arrived in Arlington with a 13-0 record, Drew Brees playing at an MVP level and the aura of a team that looked practically unbeatable.
Dallas, meanwhile, had been inconsistent and frustrating. The sort of team that could look brilliant one week and then spend the next week tackling shadows.
Yet on this night the Cowboys dominated. DeMarcus Ware harassed Brees all evening, the defence held New Orleans to just 17 points and Dallas handed the Saints their first loss of the season.
For a few hours, Cowboys fans allowed themselves to believe that perhaps, just perhaps, destiny was finally wearing a star on its helmet again. Cowboys fans are nothing if not brave.
Oklahoma State 30, Oklahoma 27, 2021 Bedlam
Bedlam games are usually strange. This one somehow managed to be stranger.
Oklahoma entered the game as the favourite and appeared ready to continue its usual routine of ruining Oklahoma State’s hopes and annoying everyone in Stillwater.
Instead, the Cowboys rallied from behind and shut down the Sooners in the second half. The defensive performance was stunning. Oklahoma State allowed almost nothing after the break, and suddenly the underdog had won Bedlam at AT&T Stadium.
The result ended Oklahoma’s playoff hopes and gave Oklahoma State one of its biggest wins in years.
What made it such a shock:
- Oklahoma had dominated the rivalry for years.
- The Sooners were expected to win and move toward another playoff run.
- Oklahoma State completely changed the game after half-time.
Jacksonville Jaguars 23, Dallas Cowboys 17, 2022
The Jaguars were improving in 2022, but few people expected them to walk into AT&T Stadium and beat a Cowboys team with playoff ambitions.
Dallas led 17-10 late in the third quarter and looked in control. Trevor Lawrence kept fighting. Jacksonville stayed aggressive.
Then came the moment every Cowboys fan would prefer to delete from history.
Dak Prescott threw an overtime interception that Rayshawn Jenkins returned for the winning touchdown. AT&T Stadium fell silent apart from a few travelling Jaguars fans who probably could not believe what they were watching either.
The Jaguars ended up reaching the playoffs. Dallas eventually recovered. Still, at the time, this felt like a genuine stunner.
Boise State 17, TCU 10, Fiesta Bowl, 2010
The Fiesta Bowl at AT&T Stadium featured two unbeaten teams from outside the traditional power conferences. TCU had the stronger defence and was expected to grind out the win.
Boise State ignored the script.
The Broncos played with confidence, controlled the game and held TCU to just 10 points. Kellen Moore looked calm throughout, while Boise State’s defence repeatedly shut down the Horned Frogs.
The upset mattered beyond the scoreline. Boise State once again proved that smaller programmes could beat the established names on the biggest stages.
At the time, it felt like half the college football world was cheering and the other half was desperately searching for an excuse.
San Francisco 49ers 23, Dallas Cowboys 17, 2021 NFC Wild Card
The Cowboys won 12 games in 2021 and entered the playoffs as one of the NFC’s hottest teams. San Francisco scraped into the postseason and looked vulnerable.
Then the 49ers ran through Dallas like they had memorised the entire Cowboys playbook.
The Cowboys looked rattled from the opening drive. Dallas committed penalties, struggled to protect Prescott and repeatedly made life harder for themselves. In fairness, they did not need any help.
The ending was almost too perfect. Dallas tried one final quarterback draw with no timeouts left. The clock expired before they could spike the ball.
AT&T Stadium sat in stunned silence while the 49ers celebrated. Somewhere, every neutral viewer in America was trying not to laugh. Most of them failed.
Stephen F. Austin 85, Duke 83, 2019
Basketball deserves a place here too.
Duke, ranked number one in the country, arrived at AT&T Stadium for what was supposed to be a routine win. Stephen F. Austin had other ideas.
The Lumberjacks played without fear and pushed Duke all night. The game went to overtime, where Stephen F. Austin completed one of the biggest shocks in recent college basketball.
Duke losing to an underdog is always funny. Duke losing in Texas to a team most casual fans could not place on a map is something close to sporting art.
Why AT&T Stadium Produces So Many Upsets
Part of it is expectation. AT&T Stadium is built for favourites. The giant video board, the national attention and the endless noise all create the feeling that the bigger team is supposed to win.
That pressure can become a problem.
The Cowboys in particular have often carried the weight of history, hype and about six million television segments asking whether this is finally their year. By the time the game starts, some teams look exhausted from hearing about themselves.
Underdogs walk into Arlington with far less to lose. They play loose, take chances and occasionally turn the place upside down.
AT&T Stadium has hosted Super Bowls, huge college games and playoff football, but its most memorable moments often come when the script catches fire and the underdog starts grinning.
TFC Takeaway
The best stadiums are not remembered because the favourite always wins. They are remembered because sometimes the impossible happens in front of 90,000 people and a giant screen large enough to replay the disaster from every angle.
AT&T Stadium has delivered plenty of those moments.
If you are a neutral fan, these upsets are glorious. If you support the team on the wrong end of one, they are the sort of memories that stay with you for years, lurking quietly until someone mentions playoff football at a family barbecue.
About the Author
